IE7 switch, the follow up

Two months ago I replaced my Firefox 2.0 with IE7. I wrote about the switch three weeks later, so I’m used to it now, used most of the features, learned the UI and shortcuts. So what was the benefits of switching? The downside, and the funny annoying stuff.

The new MS UI convention

One of the catchiest stuff in IE7 is the interface style, that is the windowing system style which has moved from classic windows(3.1, 9x,2000, and XP) to the new style(Vista), that has been used on the new Office family applications as well. The idea of tabbing and grouping functions and GUI/toolbars. IE7 is no exception, so menu bar is removed and only appears if you want it to, if you press ALT key the menu appears highlighting the File item.

Having most of the page activities grouped under a menu item on a separate toolbar with the label page that holds: saving pages, faving them, viewing source, zooming, textsize mod, etc… On the same bar there is the tools, help, print icon, RSS indication and home menu which is completly customizable. And this bar is on the same row that window-tabs aside.

T to the A to the B to the S

Opera, Safari and Firefox2 all have their close buttons on every tab. In IE7 the close(x-button) appears only on the tab that has focus so you can’t point-click-close a tab with one click. On the other hand, you can access what is called Quick Tabs which is a screen with a grid of all the open tabs with their screenshots, and every screenshot has a close button on the right-top corner.

Links bar and Favorites icons

I can’t open a browser window and start dialing URLs that I visit on daily basis, so I place them on a bar with full of links with big icons, thank god for the favicons that can save you reading and point click the icon that you want. Below is a screenshot of my browser while writing this.

Screenshot of my current IE7 look

Since I am a del.icio.us user, I wouldn’t need the Favorites stars, at least for now, so I was looking up a way to remove them from the UI, didn’t get there yet, taking the space that I don’t want to give up.

Performance, interaction and x-browser compatibility testing

I’m running on a 1GB ram + 2GHZ single Core, an IBM Thinkpad t-43. It is a little slower to start IE7 than starting FF2. Comparing to options you could get on FF2 such as spellcheck on texareas, and the wide range of extensions, IE7 comes short although some add-ons are available.

IE7 lets you know if you have Flash active-x objects on the page and informs you that you have to shift the focus to the active-x object before using it, I take that as a safe and clean way of informing users what they’re doing protecting them from sudden and unexpected clicks.

While I’ve taken IE7 for granted and been using it for testing my current designs and mark up I’m still not convinced that I could use it as my primary testing browser, FF2 still wins my heart on that.

One last thing I noticed while using IE7 is the fact that it is really slow on pages that send/receive many HTTPRequests, an example is a Netvibes page filled with RSS feeds that get updated on short intervals. FF did a better job on such pages and it was always light even while updating all my panels at the same time. Just a trade off that I can live with.

On another note I’m getting a little love back for Opera. I’ve been using the Opera Mini on my mobile, it’s flirting with me.

Related Articles

« Previous post: Music while working?
» Next post: IT Weekly to become fully online

comments

Friday December 29, 2006

CypherHackz said:

and because of that, website designers must make sure that their designs must look good in all of these browsers, including this new IE.

#

Friday December 29, 2006

Susan Shams said:

I use Opera all day long but I’m tempted by IE7, hey dot you’re just going back to your day one with Opera. Im completly the opposite IE7 is sharp and already installed, very tempting!

#

Friday December 29, 2006

Rami Kayyali said:

My primary browser is still Firefox. Things like Firebug, Web Developer Toolbar and GreaseMonkey, keep me on Firefox no matter what.

However, Opera seduces me with it’s responsiveness every time I open it. If only I could find as much extensions for Opera.

No offense, but IE7 reminds me of Quasimodo. Did you see the blank new tab tab? (No, that wasn’t a typo).

#

Friday December 29, 2006

dotone said:

Rami, “No offense” ??? Well, every UI goes through a series of evolving and this is the first iteration of the wholly new IE, I won't take the "No offense" on behalf of IE7, the new-tab-tab is somehow misguiding having no icon, as Scott Burken mentioned it while reviewing the UI, good you read that, but if you want to evaluate a peice of software, the first things you'd look at is the positives, then the negatives and shortcommings!

IE7 is not related to IE6 by any tie other than being an MS product, if that's enough to be said, I don't want to defend it but I guess being fair is not so much to do.

#

Saturday December 30, 2006

Rami Kayyali said:

Oh come on. The only real advantage of IE7 is the new revamped guts. But don’t tell me the interface doesn’t feel half-baked. It didn’t get the love Office 12 got.

#

Saturday December 30, 2006

dotone said:

Rami, I just mentioned how every UI has to evolve in the process of being more usable iteration by iteration, and also mentioned that IE7 is the first new version of IE. Half-baked, yes, it is, but I’m still curious why you call it half-baked? Have you used it? I understand that UI could be criticized after a fair use, after all it’s user experience.

“It didn’t get the love Office 12 got”, well, what measures that? They just got launched! I’ll be waiting ‘till the end of Feb ‘07, when Vista and Office get retailed. That’s something you can’t judge by some ranting here and there.

#

Saturday December 30, 2006

Rami Kayyali said:

The love that Office got can mostly be judged by their blog. I’ve been keeping up with their design decisions, and I very much like where Office ended up.

Yes, I have used IE7. Though for only one third of the time you did, I got a decent idea on what it can and cannot do.

You’re absolutely right, first iterations of software usually suck. But then again, “it’s only the first iteration” and “it’s just beta” aren’t excuses, nor do they shield developers from criticism.

You don’t have to find excuses for IE7’s team, I already have. Given the lack of time, and the management’s pressure on getting a released pushed out the door, I can understand why IE7’s interface sucks, while the rendering engine doesn’t. And that’s what I said, the only real advantage of IE7 is its revamped guts. Just think of the slew of previously-insecure browsers that were based on IE6’s engine, and how they’ll be improved automatically.

#

Saturday December 30, 2006

dotone said:

Okay, so you meant love from its team, I can’t agree with you more on that, but don’t get me wrong when I say how different Office is compared to IE in terms of complexity and interaction.

But again, the only messup that I find is the new-tab button, close buttons on focused tabs. On the flip side of the story, everything else seem to be innovative to me. Having the back/forward grouped and spacing the reload/stop by the address bar, quick tabs, font-smoothing, and zooming. It just works.

I wasn’t finding excuses for the IE7 team, nor I was defending or reviewing the browser, I was sharing my experience after switching from FF to IE7, if you were looking for reviews I can’t tell ya antythin’ but run a ‘IE7 review’ in a technorati search and be amused, and have a happy Eid :)

#

Saturday December 30, 2006

Rami Kayyali said:

Thanks man :)

And hey, I’m glad you’re back on Firefox now.

#

Saturday December 30, 2006

anil said:

thats quite a conversation i want to conclude this, say we have different tastes and different mentalities and im with IE7 having the upper hand at the moment, the more people use it and test it the more studies made hence a more matured IE7 as it is use by more.

#

Saturday December 30, 2006

Ahmad Al Hameli said:

Why you think all this Rami do you remember firefox when it was new? it was not like today. Opera is coming strong on all platform i think the next generation of web surfing users will be using opera. dotone thank you for the your post.

#

Saturday December 30, 2006

dotone said:

Rami, sure, you’re welcome.
I didn’t get back to FF, I use it as my primary testing browser though, if I ever considered switching again, it’s Opera for sure, I’m already used to OperaMini on mobile so when it works and synchronizes with the desktop Opera, then that’s the day I’m going to be an official Opera user.

Ahmad, anytime.

BTW if you guys had any kind of experience doing the same or can relate in a way, please share your thoughts and experiences here, I'm very interested in Opera, any other thoughts?

#

Commenting is closed for this article.

Want your link here? Use TLA

Posts by Topics
  1. Nov 4, 22:25 It's Orange, it's White, it's Laazi ads
  2. Oct 4, 02:20 Nakheel's Spam II
  3. Oct 2, 02:59 Nakheel's Spam
  4. Jul 23, 15:42 Social and Community with one button
  5. Jul 23, 13:58 Translate, Rebrand, and that's another Web Startup
  6. Jul 16, 07:11 10 Second Car
  7. Jul 16, 02:24 Domains of Branding
  8. Jul 14, 07:40 Outsourced Keystrokes